We write our honest review of each wine subscription plan or product, however, we might receive a commission or other compensation on the products we review to support this website. Prices can vary due to changes in promotions or policies. See our full disclosures here.

The Wine Club industry is one that has taken off in the States and the types of services that the different companies offer are becoming increasingly popular.  The only issue with the growing number of companies now providing wine club services, is that it can be a challenge to find out which wine club service will best fit your needs.  This is where we come in! At the Wine Club Review, we offer in-depth comparisons, based on our extensive first-hand experience of trying the services that these clubs offer. Today the two different wine clubs that we will be comparing is Tasting Room and Winc.

Winc is a wine club whose mission is to make your wine experience more accessible by providing a simple and easy wine club experience.  Winc has a large Californian winery offering and an easy-to-use membership process. Tasting Room has the motto of “Taste. Rate. Enjoy.” and is focussed on providing a wine experience that is personalized to your tastes, in an affordable format. So let’s dive in!

The clubs and available plans:

The Winc wine club is a subscription service that is based on a monthly delivery which includes 4 full-size bottles of wine.  You can select the option of red, white or mixed.

Tasting Room offers two different steps with their wine club:

  • Tasting Kit is the Tasting Room’s exclusive tasting kit which will assist you to ascertain what wines you prefer and to make some initial tasting notes.  The kit includes 6 mini-bottles of hand-picked wines.
  • Club box is your regular shipment which can be made up of two, six or twelve bottles that can arrive monthly or every second or third month.  You can specify if you would prefer your club box to be red, white or mixed.

Who is it for?

If you love wine but are after a wine service that is accessible and affordable then the Winc service will be well suited to you.   It is also a great choice for lovers of Californian wines.

The Tasting Room is ideal for those who enjoy both local and international wine as their wine selection includes wine from up to ten different countries.   They are also a great service for people who enjoy a glass of wine once or twice a week but are still looking for an affordable experience.

Main Benefits:

Winc:

  • Reasonable prices
  • Varied wine selection
  • Wines that are matched to your taste profile
  • Option to edit your selection
  • Option to provide tasting feedback in order to get ongoing better recommendations
  • Extra 10% off for 12 bottles and more orders

Tasting Room:

  • Affordable prices
  • Plans with flexible options
  • Large selection of wines
  • Full-size bottles that have been matched to your tasting profile
  • Ongoing process of rating your wines so that your recommendations improve over time
  • Both domestic and international wines

The personalization process:

Winc:

The Palate Profile is a savvy on-line process that Winc uses to ascertain your personal taste profile.  It is very simple, requiring you to answer six questions in order to create your one of a kind taste profile!  After you receive your first wine club box, you can then begin to submit ratings on each wine which will result in an increasingly accurate palate profile and allow for ongoing improved recommendations for your future deliveries.

Tasting Room:

Your Tasting Profile is created by using an easy online process where you are required to answer three short questions that assesses your initial profile.  The next step is that you receive the tasting kit which is made up of 6 mini-bottles that you taste and rank via the Tasting Room website.  After you have ranked the wines, your profile will be completed. Your tasting profile is constantly updated and improved as you provide feedback on subsequent deliveries.  

The website and ordering process:

Both Winc and Tasting Room have very easy to follow subscription processes and websites that are easy to navigate.

The Winc website allows you to explore its wine selection and find out details about the club concept and their team.   To start the process, you simply need to create your palate profile, stipulate your preferred type of box (red, white or mix) and then create your account.   You will see your wine selection recommendation and you can edit your order if you wish and add or delete items until you are happy with your delivery. Winc also offers the option to ‘Skip a Month’ which can be used whenever you do not want to receive a monthly order.  It is also easy to cancel your subscription online or via their customer support team.

With the Tasting Room you simply complete your tasting profile but answer a few quick questions, create your account and order the tasting kit.  After you have enjoyed your tasting kit you rank the wines via your online account. You will then receive your first club delivery only 24 hours later!    With Tasting Room, you can update your delivery preferences at any time and you can also skip delivery whenever required. Cancellation is also possible via your online account and is hassle free.

Please be aware that with any wine deliveries that someone 21+ must be available to sign for the order at delivery.

Tasting Room White Wine
Tasting Room Wine
Winc Wine Lable
Winc Wine

The wines:

Our job at the Wine Club Review is to taste the deliveries from each company that we review, so you can rest assured that our opinions are gained first-hand and are genuine.   We were very pleased with most of the wines we tasted from both Winc and Tasting Room.

Winc is a Californian-based winery offering a unique online membership experience.  Their team is responsible for putting together a large selection of over a hundred often unique wines.   Their selections ranges from classic blends to quite obscure single vineyard projects. The wines are bottled by Winc and seem to be based around the idea that drinking wine should be an enjoyable and hassle-free experience.   

As Tasting Room is an international winery collective, you will find a range of domestic and international wines in their selection.  These countries include France, Italy, Argentina and America, to name a few. Tasting Room provides a wide variety of wines and as they avoid the middleman and bring the wine directly to their members, they can provide wines at substantial savings.

tasting-room-logo

Bottom Line:

We really enjoyed our experience with both Winc and Tasting Room and believe that they would appeal to a similar audience.  In this instance, our preferred company was Tasting Room as their wines tended to be better value for money and they offered a great selection of quality domestic and international wines. Plus, we also loved the flexibility of their Club box plan.

tasting-room-logo

Tasting Room is our Winner!

  • Affordable price wines
  • Flexible plan options
  • Great selection of wines
  • Rate your wines as you go and enjoy recommendations that improve from shipment to shipment
  • Close Menu