We write our honest review on each product, however, we might receive compensation on the products we review to support this website. See our full disclosures here

BLOG

Is FirstLeaf Worth It? Our Honest Review

A wine subscription service can introduce you to a whole range of excellent wines you never about. Both newbies and experienced wine lovers can enjoy all the benefits that wine subscriptions can bring. There are lots of options available, and one of these is Firstleaf.

You could have heard of Firstleaf from various wine industry publications, from an ad, or maybe even from a friend or connection. We decided to try Firstleaf for ourselves to find out what all the buzz is about.

Enjoy our Firstleaf wine club review to learn about the company, see what we thought of the service, and to help you decide if you want to give it a try as well. This wine club has a lot going for it, so let’s get right into it.

Firstleaf Main Benefits

Before signing up for any wine subscription services, we like to dig around first for some background information.

As for the question – Is Firstleaf legit? The answer is a big yes!

We found that this company is very credible. It was founded by Philip James, a British entrepreneur, and adventurer based in California, where it is located.  The mission behind the service is to become the most customer-centric wine service. This is achieved through a robust system of analyzing wine data, customer ratings, and wine preferences. 

As it stands, three main factors make Firstleaf stand out:

  • Personalized wine selections based on the thumbs up ratings from customers
  • Incredible value and access to affordably priced quality local and imported wines
  • Lots of flexibility  – choose your wines, skip deliveries, or cancel at any time.

If you’re still wondering how exactly the subscription service works, we’ve got you covered. When you join the club, you take a short quiz for Firstleaf to determine your wine preferences. Next, you receive an introductory order of quality wines delivered to you. After you have rated these, you start receiving curated club orders.

More benefits of joining the club include:

  • A 100% satisfaction guarantee
  • Great variety of award-winning wines
  • The Firstleaf community of over 100,000 fellow wine lovers, using a smart ranking system.
  • An exclusive wine concierge team
  • Excellent customer service available for extended hours daily

Our Try with Firstleaf 

We decided to try out a wine box from Firstleaf to taste their wines for ourselves. It was also an opportunity to experience every aspect of the service for ourselves—from the signup and ordering process to the delivery and, finally, to the best part of sampling the wine selection from Firstleaf.

Placing an order on the website was easy enough to do. We were very excited when our wine box arrived a few days later. The packaging was very impressive; our wine bottles were in good condition when they came. We also enjoyed all the company information, wine information, and the newsletter in the box.

Every wine club has a unique style and its pros and cons. There was a lot that we loved about the service and the whole experience. We wished that the rating system could be different after you get your bottles of wine delivered.

Because Firstleaf does a lot of data analysis, the rating is simplified to a thumbs up or down. It could be great if we could also share comments on our experience.

You are probably ready to hear about our experience with each of the five bottles of wine we tried from Firstleaf. Here is some information on the wines we tried, their taste, the prizes they have won, and our general experience with each of them. 

Le Douleur Exquise 2019 Grenache

This French red wine has over 13 awards to its name, including the Best of Class in the 2020 International Women’s Wine Competition and 98 Points in the 2020 Sunset Magazine International Wine Competition. The wine comes from the oldest wine-making region in France, Languedoc-Roussillon, or “Pays d’Oc.”

Le Douleur Exquise is a classic medium-bodied French Grenache and features a rich fruitiness. You can catch the pomegranate, strawberry, and raspberry flavors.

Using the helpful tasting and pairing notes, we tried this wine alongside a dish of braised beef and mushrooms, and we loved how the fruity flavors were enhanced. 

Isolde’s Rapture 2018 Syrah

This is another award-winning wine of the Syrah variation. It has ten awards in total, including the Best Syrah in the 2020 Critics Challenge: International Wine Competition and 95 Points in the 2020 Critics Challenge: International Wine Competition. Isolde’s Rapture comes from Monterey County, California.

We loved the bold mix of dark berries, chocolate, and spice flavors. The combination with a pork dish only made the wine better.

Tintoretto 2019 Sangiovese

The Tintoretto is another award-winning wine, this time a classic Italian Sangiovese. It features the signature dusty tannins and juicy, savory flavors we know so well from other wines in this variety.

With five awards in the bag, the Tintoretto has most recently won 91 Points in the 2020 Sommelier Choice Awards, the Gold Medal also in the 2020 Sommelier Choice Awards, and the Silver Medal in the 2020 USA Wine Ratings.

The flavor of the Tintoretto is composed of sour cherry, strawberry, and a leathery taste. You can also savor the herb and balsamic taste in the wine. As recommended, we paired this wine with a tomato-based dish. We chose a creamy tomato pasta and enjoyed the combination. 

Watchful Maker 2017 Cabernet Sauvignon

The Watchful Maker is a classic Cabernet Sauvignon from the Columbia Valley in Washington.  Many people are not as familiar with this beautiful wine region as they are with California’s wine areas.

This Cabernet Sauvignon has landed three awards: 90 Points in the 2020 Harvest Challenge, the Gold Medal in the 2020 Harvest Challenge, and the Silver Medal in the 2020 USA Wine Ratings. This textured wine had great berry flavors, and you can easily catch the richness of blackcurrant, raspberry, blueberry, and a touch of mocha.

This local wine also paired well with different meat dishes. We love the great texture that comes with a classic Cabernet Sauvignon.

Rancho Campo 2018 Malbec

The last of the five Firstleaf wines we tried was the Rancho Campo. This wine is a bold Malbec from the Mendoza region in Argentina. The stand-out flavors include violet, plum, blackberry, vanilla, and cocoa.

The Rancho Campo has landed two awards, namely the Silver Medal in the 2020 USA Wine Ratings and another Silver Medal in the 2020 Sommelier Choice Awards. From the Firstleaf wine card, we learned that this wine pairs well with grilled vegetables, empanadas, and desserts. It is a full-bodied wine and went well with a meal off the grill.

Final Thoughts – Thumbs Up or Thumbs Down?

Our final verdict after trying the Firstleaf wine club is defiantly thumbs up!

One of the standout features was the quality of the wines, both local and imported. You get a wide selection of wines to try from this subscription plan. We appreciated the personalization process, from the initial quiz to the opportunities to rank each of the wines we tried to improve the matching. 

We noted that becoming a Firstleaf club member is an affordable option for the quality experience and wines we receive. 

We were able to get a great coupon for our readers –  for even more savings on your wine. So make sure to use it when ordering. Cheers!

BLOG
Partner wine clubs
POSTS
Recent Posts
red wine vs white wine
BLOG
You Might Also Like
red wine vs white wine
RED WINE VS WHITE WINE – WHICH ONE SUITS YOU BETTER?
Plonk Wine
Best Online Wine Clubs for 2022
winc white wine
Our Winc White Wine Review 2022
affordable wine clubs
Are Wine Clubs Worth It?
What Are the Different Colors of Wine?
natural wine benefits
Is Natural Wine Better For You?
WSJ wine club
Recommended Wine Openers
Winc wine club
Our Winc Red Wines Review
WSJ wine
Is WSJ Wine A Good Deal?
Firstleaf Wine selection
Our Honest Take – Is Firstleaf Worth It?
Best Wines for Thanksgiving Dinner
red wine sex
Is Red Wine Good for Sex?
Pink Rose Wine
How to Choose the Right Wine?
Best Tools and Techniques to Store and Preserve Wine
Best Tools and Techniques to Store and Preserve Wine
Best Wine Countries
Best Wine Countries
Wine Club FAQ
Wine Club FAQ: What You Need to Know
How to Prevent Teeth Staining From Red Wine
How to Prevent Teeth Staining From Red Wine
champagne-bottle
Wine Clubs – Not Only for Rich People
The Wine Club Reviews
Mother’s Day Wine Club Gift Card
Father’s Day Wine Gifts
Father’s Day Wine Gifts
VDay Wine and Food
Food and Wine Pairing for Valentine’s Day Dinner Date
wine experts
Do I Need to Be a Wine Expert to Join a Wine Club?
Health Benefits of Wine
Health Benefits of Wine
martha stewart wine club
What’s the Best Wine Club to Join?
french wine guide
A Guide To French Wines
Coronavirus wine clubs
The Best Wine Clubs to Join if You are Stuck at Home due to Coronavirus
Hello fresh wine box
Best Wine Clubs for Beginners
Why is Wine so Popular
Why is Wine So Popular?
champagne-bottle
15 Fun Facts About Champagne
Wine Glasses
15 Fun Facts About Wine
WSJ Wine Club
How to Cancel Your WSJ Wine Club Account
Winc Wine Subscription
How to Cancel Your Winc Wine Club Account
Firstleaf Wine selection
The Effect of Temperature on Food and Wine Matching
NakedWines wine club review
How Food Can Make Your Wine Shine
WSJ Wine Club
Wine Experiences Are the New Wine Tastings
WSJ Wine Club
Food and Wine Pairing – Your Guide to Being an Excellent Host
Why is Wine so Popular
8 Things You Need to Know about Hosting a Wine Dinner Party
Father’s Day Wine Gifts
Decanting Wine: The Whys, Hows, and Everything in Between
Wine Serving Temperature
All About Wine Serving Temperature: Do’s and Don’ts
open a wine bottle
Wine Storage 101: How Long Can You Keep an Opened Bottle of Wine
Best Wine for Tacos
Best Wine for Tacos
NakedWines wine club review
Best Wine Pairings for Fish and Seafood
best wine and cheese pairings
Best Wine and Cheese Pairings
Pairing wine and pizza
Best Wine Pairings for Pizza
best wine to go with steak
Best Wine Pairing with Steak
Best White Wines
Complete Guide to the Most Common White Wines
The Wine Club Reviews about us
Complete Guide to the Most Common Red Wines
choose wine club
Recommended Wine Glasses
California Wine Club box
Recommended Wine Gadgets
choose wine club
How to Choose a Wine Club Service
Most affordable wine clubs
5 Reasons To Use a Wine Club
California Wine Club Red Wine
What Is a Wine Club Service?
Wine deals 2022